Skip to Main Content

CPSC 240: Computer Ethics - Gavazzi: Evaluate Sources

Evaluate Sources

Media Bias Chart

💡 Tip: Choose sources that rank high in reliability (higher on the chart) and close to the center for bias. If a source falls low on reliability or far left/right on the chart, double-check the information with a more neutral, fact-focused outlet. 

Note: Not all local or academic sources appear on the chart — that’s okay. Use it mainly to evaluate major news outlets.

The SIFT Method

A step-by-step process to help uncover the truth behind a website, image, video, or online source. 

SIFT Evaluating Sources

Based on the work of Mike Caulfield, Washington State University.

Investigate the Source

Always check who made a source and why. A Nobel Prize economist? Useful to know. A video from the dairy industry? Also important context.

Fact-checkers don’t just stay on one page — they read laterally, jumping to other sites to see what’s being said and piecing together the bigger picture.

Lateral Reading = Reading Across Websites

  • Open other tabs right away, don’t just rely on the source itself
  • Look up the author, organization, or publisher on trusted sites
  • Compare across multiple sources to spot patterns or red flags
  • Decide whether the source is credible before using it

📺 Watch this 2:44 video to see lateral reading in action (hint: Wikipedia is a great shortcut!)

Find the Original

Things online often lose their context. A short video clip, a cropped photo, or a headline about research may not tell the whole story — and sometimes it’s misleading on purpose.

To be sure, trace what you see back to the original source and check if it was reported accurately.

Tracing = Going Upstream to the Source

  • Find the full video, image, or article instead of relying on a clip or repost
  • Check whether the research or quote actually says what’s claimed
  • Look for the first/original reporting before re-shares added spin
  • Compare how different outlets present the same event or study

📺 Watch this 1:33 video on re-reporting vs. original sources (and how to go “upstream” to check).

  • All Sides - Provides balanced news, media bias ratings, diverse perspectives, and real conversation.
  • FactCheck - A nonpartisan, nonprofit “consumer advocate” for voters that aims to reduce the level of deception and confusion in U.S. politics.
  • Politifact - A fact-checking website that rates the accuracy of claims by elected officials and others on its Truth-O-Meter.
  • Snopes - Investigates rumors and news stories from across the internet, covering a variety of topics.
  • Media Bias/Fact Check - A comprehensive media bias resource on the internet. There are currently 5700+ media sources and journalists listed.
Footer Example